Critical Analysis of a Technological Event Through an Interdisciplinary Lens

2/13/23, 3:47 PM https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html

Need answer to this question?

Course Outcomes

In this project, you will demonstrate your mastery of the following competency:

Analyze the evolving role of technology in one’s discipline of study or chosen profession by investigating the influence of technology on modern culture Integrate interdisciplinary approaches for determining how technology affects modern identity in personal and professional contexts

Explain how technology influences modern society by employing appropriate research strategies Recommend strategies for utilizing current technology to meet personal and professional goals

Articulate informed viewpoints on how technology shapes the world and can influence change using effective communication skills

Assess the impact of emerging technologies on societal issues for incorporating diverse perspectives and viewpoints informed by relevant literature and interpersonal experiences

Overview

This course explores technology and its impact on the world around us. Technology influences society and society influences technology, creating a feedback loop between them. You will critically analyze a feedback loop in this project through social, historical, and cultural approaches to technology with the aid of the four general education lenses: history, humanities, natural and applied sciences, and social sciences. From this enhanced understanding, you will be equipped to draw connections among technology, self, and society. These skills are often necessary to achieve personal and professional goals across many disciplines.

Directions

For this project, you will write a 10-page paper that examines a social, cultural, or global event where a technology plays a significant role. In the paper, you will describe your chosen technology and event, construct a thesis statement, perform a critical analysis that makes use of at least one of the general education lenses, and reflect on how your analysis can inform your personal life and experience. You will demonstrate your ability to think critically, investigate, and communicate clearly.

Specifically, you must address the following rubric criteria:

  1. Evidence: You will use evidence to support your analysis throughout the project.
    1. Integrate reliable evidence from varied sources throughout your paper to support your analysis. Use at least two resources from the Module Resources sections of this course and two resources that you find through your own research using the Shapiro Library.
      1. It is important to draw from a more diverse pool of perspectives from varied sources to support the analysis. This is different from the Citations and Attributions rubric criterion.
      2. Reliable evidence from varied sources should be interwoven throughout the paper itself, while citing and attributing sources will be represented as APA in-text citations and a reference list at the end of your work.
      3. You will be evaluated on both criteria.
  2. Technology and Event Description: In this section, you will identify and discuss the factors that shape your thesis statement.
    1. Describe a social, cultural, or global event where a technology plays a significant role. Include information such as how the event originated and what it is about.
    2. Describe the technology significant to this event. Include information such as what the technology does and how it may help influence change.
    3. Assess the societal or cultural influences of the technology involved in the event.
    4. Explain your choice of general education interdisciplinary lens for analyzing the technology and its role in the event.
    5. Construct a thesis statement that combines your event, the technology, the societal or cultural influences, and choice of general education interdisciplinary lens.

https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html 1/7

2/13/23, 3:47 PM https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html

  1. Critical Analysis: In this section, you will analyze your technology’s role in the event using one of the general education lenses and recommend strategies for using this kind of analysis to meet your personal and professional goals.
    1. Analyze your technology’s role in the event through one of the general education interdisciplinary lenses to determine the technology’s impact on various institutions.
    2. Analyze how social practices have been shaped by the technology involved in the event.
    3. Describe at least one limitation of the technology involved in the event that could benefit from change.
    4. Recommend strategies to address the limitations of the technology involved in the event.
    5. Assess at least two significant factors that could affect how individuals understand the role of technology in the event, such as biases, beliefs, assumptions, and/or values.
    6. Assess the benefits and challenges of critically analyzing technology in society.
    7. Recommend strategies for using this kind of critical analysis for meeting your personal goals.
      1. What might this look like in your everyday life? Consider how critically analyzing technology influence on a particular event can be used to address day-to-day responsibilities.
  2. Reflection: In this section, you will describe how using critical analysis tools influences your personal experience, your field of study or profession, and how you interact with others.
    1. Describe how critically analyzing a technology’s role in an event has informed your individual framework of perception.
      1. Consider how it has altered the way you perceive the world.
    2. Describe how examining your bias may alter the way you use or don’t use certain technologies.
      1. Reflect on your own bias, then consider how an awareness of one’s bias can change how one interacts with technology.
    3. Explain how critically analyzing a technology’s role in your event can influence your field of study or profession.
      1. How can studying technology inform your understanding of the next big topic of study in your field or profession?
    4. Explain at least one way in which your analysis might have been different had you used one of the other general education lenses to analyze the technology’s role in your event.
    5. Explain how analyzing the technology’s role in your event can help interactions with those of a different viewpoint, culture, and perspective.

What to Submit

To complete this project, you must submit a Word document of 10 pages in length (plus a reference page) using 12-point Times New Roman font, double spacing, and one-inch margins. Use at least two resources from the Module Resources sections of this course and two resources that you find through your own research using the Shapiro Library. Sources should be cited according to APA style. Consult the Shapiro Library APA Style Guide for more information on citations.

Project Rubric

CriteriaExemplary (100%)Proficient (85%)Needs Improvement (55%)Not Evident (0%)Value
Reliable Evidence From VariedExceeds proficiency in anIntegrates reliable evidenceShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Sourcesexceptionally clear,from varied sourcesproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, orthroughout the paper toor omissions; areas for
creative mannersupport analysis, including atimprovement may include
least two resources from thedrawing from a more diverse
Module Resources sectionspool of perspectives, using
of the course and twomore varied sources to
resources found throughsupport the analysis, or using
independent research usingat least two resources from
the Shapiro Librarythe Module Resources
sections of the course and

https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html 2/7

2/13/23, 3:47 PM https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html

CriteriaExemplary (100%)Proficient (85%)Needs Improvement (55%)Not Evident (0%)Value
two resources found through independent research using the Shapiro Library
Technology and Event Description: Social, Cultural or Global EventExceeds proficiency in an exceptionally clear, insightful, sophisticated, or creative mannerDescribes a social, cultural, or global event where a technology plays a significant role, including how the event originated and what it is aboutShows progress toward proficiency, but with errors or omissions; areas for improvement may include providing a more thorough description of the event, clear connection to the role of technology, or additional contextual information about the eventDoes not attempt criterion5
Technology and Event Description: TechnologyExceeds proficiency in an exceptionally clear, insightful, sophisticated, or creative mannerDescribes the technology significant to the event, including what the technology does and how it may help influence changeShows progress toward proficiency, but with errors or omissions; areas for improvement may include a more thorough description or greater support regarding the technology, what it does, or how it may help influence changeDoes not attempt criterion5
Technology and EventExceeds proficiency in anAssesses the societal orShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Description: Societal orexceptionally clear,cultural influences of theproficiency, but with errors
Cultural Influencesinsightful, sophisticated, ortechnology involved in theor omissions; areas for
creative mannereventimprovement may include
providing a more thorough
or detailed assessment of
how society or culture
influences the technology
involved in the event or
providing more support for
that assessment
Technology and EventExceeds proficiency in anExplains choice of generalShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Description: Generalexceptionally clear,education interdisciplinaryproficiency, but with errors
Education Lensinsightful, sophisticated, orlens for analyzing theor omissions; areas for
creative mannertechnology and its role in theimprovement may include
eventconnecting one of the four
general education lenses to
the role of the technology in
the event or providing a
more convincing or thorough
explanation of why the lens
was chosen

https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html 3/7

2/13/23, 3:47 PM https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html

CriteriaExemplary (100%)Proficient (85%)Needs Improvement (55%)Not Evident (0%)Value
Technology and Event Description: Thesis StatementExceeds proficiency in an exceptionally clear, insightful, sophisticated, or creative mannerConstructs a thesis statement that combines the event, technology, societal or cultural influences, and choice of general education interdisciplinary lensShows progress toward proficiency, but with errors or omissions; areas for improvement may include a clearer or more concise thesis statement that integrates event, technology, societal or cultural influences, and choice of general education lensDoes not attempt criterion5
Critical Analysis: Impact onExceeds proficiency in anAnalyzes the technology’sShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Institutionsexceptionally clear,role in the event through aproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, orgeneral educationor omissions; areas for
creative mannerinterdisciplinary lens toimprovement may include
determine the technology’susing one of the lenses to
impact on variousanalyze the technology’s role
institutionsin the event, conducting a
deeper analysis of the impact
of the technology on various
institutions through the
chosen lens, or providing
greater support for the
analysis
Critical Analysis: SocialExceeds proficiency in anAnalyzes how socialShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Practicesexceptionally clear,practices have been shapedproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, orby the technology involvedor omissions; areas for
creative mannerin the eventimprovement may include
conducting a deeper analysis
of how social practices have
been shaped by a specific
technology, or providing
greater support for the
analysis
Critical Analysis: LimitationExceeds proficiency in anDescribes at least oneShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
That Could Benefit Fromexceptionally clear,limitation of the technologyproficiency, but with errors
Changeinsightful, sophisticated, orinvolved that could benefitor omissions; areas for
creative mannerfrom changeimprovement may include
providing more thorough
support of why the chosen
limitation could benefit from
change or adding more detail
about the kind of limitation
described
Critical Analysis: Strategies to Address the LimitationsExceeds proficiency in an exceptionally clear,Recommends strategies for how to address theShows progress toward proficiency, but with errorsDoes not attempt criterion5

https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html 4/7

2/13/23, 3:47 PM https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html

CriteriaExemplary (100%)Proficient (85%)Needs Improvement (55%)Not Evident (0%)Value
insightful, sophisticated, orlimitations of the technologyor omissions; areas for
creative mannerinvolved in the eventimprovement may include
providing more relevant or
appropriate strategies for
how to address the
limitations of the technology,
or providing a more
thorough explanation of the
strategies selected or the
reason why they were
recommended
Critical Analysis: Factors ThatExceeds proficiency in anAssesses at least twoShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Could Impact Understandingexceptionally clear,significant factors that couldproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, orimpact how individualsor omissions; areas for
creative mannerunderstand the role ofimprovement may include
technology in the event,identifying two specific
such as biases, beliefs,factors that could affect how
assumptions, and/or valuesindividuals understand the
role of technology in the
event, or providing more
thorough support for choice
of factors
Critical Analysis: Benefits andExceeds proficiency in anAssesses the benefits andShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Challengesexceptionally clear,challenges of criticallyproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, oranalyzing technology inor omissions; areas for
creative mannersocietyimprovement may include
connecting the benefits and
challenges assessed to
technology, providing a more
detailed assessment of
these, or providing more
support for them or how
they relate to technology in
society
Critical Analysis: Strategies forExceeds proficiency in anRecommends strategies forShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Personal Goalsexceptionally clear,using critical analysis forproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, ormeeting personal goalsor omissions; areas for
creative mannerimprovement may include
providing more relevant or
appropriate strategies for
using critical analysis for
meeting personal, or
providing a more thorough
explanation of the strategies
selected or the reason why
they were recommended

https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html 5/7

2/13/23, 3:47 PM https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html

CriteriaExemplary (100%)Proficient (85%)Needs Improvement (55%)Not Evident (0%)Value
Reflection: IndividualExceeds proficiency in anDescribes how criticallyShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Framework of Perceptionexceptionally clear,analyzing a technology’s roleproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, orin an event has informedor omissions; areas for
creative mannerindividual framework ofimprovement may include
perceptionproviding additional details
or a more specific
description of how critically
analyzing a technology’s role
in an event has informed
individual framework of
perception
Reflection: BiasExceeds proficiency in an exceptionally clear, insightful, sophisticated, or creative mannerDescribes how examining bias may alter the use or lack of use of certain technologiesShows progress toward proficiency, but with errors or omissions; areas for improvement may include clearly connecting bias and the use or lack of use of certain technologies, or providing more thorough support for how examining bias may alter this usageDoes not attempt criterion5
Reflection: Field of Study orExceeds proficiency in anExplains how criticallyShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Professionexceptionally clear,analyzing a technology’s roleproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, orin an event can influenceor omissions; areas for
creative mannerfield of study or professionimprovement may include
connecting the critical
analysis of a technology’s
role in an event to an
academic or professional
experience, or providing
more thorough support for
this connection
Reflection: Different GeneralExceeds proficiency in anExplains at least one way theShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
Education Lensexceptionally clear,analysis might have beenproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, ordifferent if another generalor omissions; areas for
creative mannereducation lens was used toimprovement may include
analyze the technology’s roleuse of an alternative general
in the eventeducation lens, a clearer
explanation of how the
analysis might have been
different if one of the other
general education lenses had
been used to analyze the
technology’s role in the
event, or more support for
the explanation

https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html 6/7

2/13/23, 3:47 PM https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html

CriteriaExemplary (100%)Proficient (85%)Needs Improvement (55%)Not Evident (0%)Value
Reflection: InteractionsExceeds proficiency in anExplains how analyzing theShows progress towardDoes not attempt criterion5
exceptionally clear,technology’s role in theproficiency, but with errors
insightful, sophisticated, orevent can help interactionsor omissions; areas for
creative mannerwith those of a differentimprovement may include
viewpoint, culture, orconnecting the value of
perspectivecritical analysis to
interactions with people with
a different viewpoint,
culture, or perspective, or
providing a more thorough
explanation of how the
analysis can help these
interactions
Articulation of ResponseExceeds proficiency in an exceptionally clear, insightful, sophisticated, or creative mannerClearly conveys meaning with correct grammar, sentence structure, and spelling, demonstrating an understanding of audience and purposeShows progress toward proficiency, but with errors in grammar, sentence structure, and spelling, negatively impacting readabilitySubmission has critical errors in grammar, sentence structure, and spelling, preventing understanding of ideas5
Citations and AttributionsUses citations for ideas requiring attribution, with few or no minor errorsUses citations for ideas requiring attribution, with consistent minor errorsUses citations for ideas requiring attribution, with major errorsDoes not use citations for ideas requiring attribution5
Total:100%

https://learn.snhu.edu/content/enforced/1231283-IDS-403-J3080-OL-TRAD-UG.23EW3/Project Guidelines and Rubric.html 7/7

Scroll to Top